Thursday, May 14, 2009
New Blog
http://crumbsatthefeast.blogspot.com/
I've also decided that I will spend the rest of the Easter season not blogging. (Seems fair after lent, eh?) So while there's nothing up at the above site besides the name, expect some activity around Pentecost. Do not, however, expect an entry every day. Lent is lent, and no need to inflict it on everyone year 'round. :)
Sunday, April 12, 2009
Sunday
When the sabbath was over, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome bought spices, so that they might go and anoint him. 2And very early on the first day of the week, when the sun had risen, they went to the tomb. 3They had been saying to one another, “Who will roll away the stone for us from the entrance to the tomb?” 4When they looked up, they saw that the stone, which was very large, had already been rolled back. 5As they entered the tomb, they saw a young man, dressed in a white robe, sitting on the right side; and they were alarmed. 6But he said to them, “Do not be alarmed; you are looking for Jesus of Nazareth, who was crucified. He has been raised; he is not here. Look, there is the place they laid him. 7But go, tell his disciples and Peter that he is going ahead of you to Galilee; there you will see him, just as he told you.” 8So they went out and fled from the tomb, for terror and amazement had seized them; and they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.
Saturday, April 11, 2009
Saturday
What next?
How next?
It can be that way with any loss. Or victory, for that matter. Sometimes there's not much difference between the two. A new absence, a new presence---both bring a change in your life. The old has passed away. All things are new.
But right after the funeral, right after the final goodbyes, the new is not so wonderful. Old patterns, old normal is gone. We just can't see how the next day will make sense. We can't see . . . . That's just it. We just can't see.
We walk by faith, not by sight.
A surprising new normal is coming.
Friday, April 10, 2009
Friday
When Christ calls a man, he bids him come and die. Dietrich Bonhoeffer. He knew what he was talking about, I guess.
What does it mean to die to yourself? What does it mean to give your life for another?
Abba Poemen said, "When you hear someone complaining and you struggle with yourself and do not answer him back with complaints; when you are hurt and bear it patiently, not looking for revenge; then you are laying down your life for your neighbor."
I take this stuff seriously. It mostly paralyzes me, but I take it seriously.
I sometimes wonder what it would look like for the church to die. What would it look like if the corporate church were to put on the mind of Christ who, though he was in the form of God, did not take equality with God as something to be grasped at but emptied himself, taking on the form of a slave. What if the church sold all its buildings and furniture and real estate, gave it to the poor, and followed Jesus to the cross? It doesn't even seem possible, does it? Because all those buildings and furniture and real estate are useful. They can be used to further the work of God. They can also become the whole reason for the church existing. So much goes into the upkeep of the physical plant. So much of the church's resources go into self-preservation and its sometimes hard to see the emptying out.
But, as we were told to sing years ago, we are the church. And I'm not so good at emptying myself. I don't personally know anyone who is. It's no wonder that collectively we fail to do it as well.
But Christ calls us, and there is dying involved in the call. Dying to self. To put others before us takes a little out of us, is a small death. To give to charity when you want some shiny new toy is another death. To help someone on the side of the road when we're in a hurry to get somewhere, that's a little death. We might manage those. Sometimes. It makes small differences.
I heard someone say recently---I can't recall where---that death is a miracle. I can go along with that. It seems unnatural to stop breathing. It seems unlikely that it'll happen to us. It's hard to believe.
But there's something in our faith that speaks of death as a choice. Not as a suicidal thing, not as a killing sort of thing, but as a sacrificial sort of thing. Love takes something out of you. It is also sustaining and rejuvenating, but let's not fool ourselves, it also takes something.
There is an argument to be had as to where or not Jesus went willingly to the cross, but I'm not interested in that argument, not tonight. What I think is more interesting is that Jesus made choices that he had to have known would make powerful people angry. He did this even though he knew it could cost him his life. He taught, healed, helped even when he knew it would rub people the wrong way. And as much as I trust in the resurrection, I have to say---I'm often quite afraid to do that. I'm not willing to put myself out there in the same way that Jesus did.
I'm not willing to empty myself. Not often. Hardly every.
Jesus ended up on the cross---what a failure! I love the business books that speak of success in terms of how Jesus became a success. They read a different Bible than I do. Jesus did what was right, did everything right, and still ended up on a cross, a victim of a state sanctioned execution.
I'm not willing to be that big of a failure. I'm afraid of dying that big a death.
But that's our story today. Follow Jesus, get a cross. Follow Jesus---he calls you to die. Follow Jesus and learn to not hold grudges, to forgive, to take no revenge.
"Teach me to live that I may dread the grave as little as my bed.
Teach me to die that so I may rise glorious at the awesome day."
This is serious stuff. This is deathly serious stuff. And, to bring it around to the supposed topic of this blog, it bothers me that all sides of the argument around GLBT stuff (or just about any argument within a church, for that matter) are defending themselves, speaking ill of othe other side, not willing to die for the other. I'm in the thick of that. I'm not entirely sure how to die to myself in this argument. I'm not sure how to give my life for someone with whom I fundamentally disagree.
God, save us by your grace. We're certainly not going to get saved by works here.
Follow Jesus. Take up a cross and follow Jesus. Be willing to do what Jesus did, even though you know it will create powerful enemies. it will get ugly, maybe even bloody, and it'll likely be your own blood.
It was Jesus's own blood. And after all of it was done, Jesus gave up his spirit and said, "It is finished."
But in each ending, there is a beginning . . .
Thursday, April 9, 2009
Thursday
I'll tell you I go to church and then almost apologize. You know how those people are that go to church. And you understand, I'm not that type of church-goer, okay? I mean, if they think I'm that kind of Jesus follower, that won't help evangelism---it's important to know that there are many kinds of people who call Jesus "Lord," right? And if I'm a bit embarrassed by my church, or certain factions of it, that's understandable, right? It just does no one any good to always be shouting, "I follow Jesus."
It sometimes feels like . . . You know, I want to follow Jesus. I find Jesus so compelling, so much like how I wish I could be. Willing to speak truth to power. Willing to trade the facade of power for servanthood. Able to reach out to the undesirables of society and make a difference in their lives. But there's an awful lot of people between me and Jesus at this points. Crowds and crowds, and sometimes I can't see over them to see Jesus. Sometimes there is confusion about where Jesus is leading. "This way," says one person. "No, he went thataway," says another. Some of them are clearly wrong, some are less so. Worst of all, the crowd that is actually following Jesus is sometimes indiscernible from the ones who only think they are. Plants the seed of doubt in my brain as to who I'm actually following.
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
Wednesday
Each year, I take the Triduum off from work. I've come to look at it a bit like a religious retreat for which I don't have to travel. I go to all the services my church offers (yes, even the 3-hour 7-last-words service on Friday afternoon). I assist at the Saturday vigil (I savor the chance to read the story of the three young men in the fiery furnace again---perhaps the funniest story in all the Bible and I read it so that people know they can laugh and still learn from scripture). But I also try very hard to take time to breath, be still, RETREAT. I don't slow down well, and although I know it is a busy busy time for clergy everywhere, I take advantage of the chance to stop and think and pray and reflect. It's weeks like this that I'm glad that I didn't just go ahead and get ordained after seminary. Besides being ill-suited for ordained ministry, I would come to resent this time, which is truly my most favorite time of the year.
It's Wednesday in Holy Week and I just realized how . . . not quite right it seems to say I find these days as days to slow down and breathe. Jesus would surely be feeling the heat by now, even as his disciples remain somewhat clueless. Judas, perhaps, has already made his deal, or is on the verge of it, but the rest of the twelve appear unaware. They surely sense some tension, but maybe they just experience it as excitement. Maybe they think this is the time for Jesus to assert his Messiah-dom, to bring in his kingdom, to take back Jerusalem from the Romans. It's all coming to a head and I want to be still and reflect.
Well, that's the benefit of having read ahead in the story, I suppose, the benefit of living in a post-Easter world.
Except, of course, we all live in this space of uncertain expectations, maybe even false expectations. We all wish for some things that just aren't going to materialize. And the excitement we feel? Maybe it's just stress from the people around us who are paying closer attention.
Apply that, as you see fit, to the current situation that's going on in the ELCA.
It's Wednesday in Holy Week. How are you feeling?
Tuesday, April 7, 2009
Tuesday
I'll admit to something: at this point on the timeline, I don't fully believe that the ELCA Churchwide Assembly will pass the documents before them regarding human sexuality. I also can't believe that they'd vote it down. I have faith and doubt in vascillating measures. Well, Frederick Buechner once said that doubt was not the opposite of faith, but a component of it. Yea, verily.
I've spent a lot of chronos waiting for validation from the church. I wonder if that's always been my "problem," the root of my constant involvement at church throughout my life. I want to be told that I'm okay. This goes beyond sexuality. It's probably pathological and deserves some serious couch time.
I'm also waiting for kairos. I have some sense of God's timing, I do. I'm also increasingly aware of passing chronos. Will my chronos intersect with the church's kairos? In some ways it's too late.
I speak of the importance of these documents, so that another generation of children doesn't grow up think GLBT folk can't be pastors. This is important, but today I was reflecting on all the ways allowing openly GLBT folk be pastors can affect a young person's vocational choice---it doesn't have to be about becoming a pastor.
Back in college, as a theater major, I took dance classes. I apparently had some ability. I had dance teachers asking me to declare a double major or at least a dance minor. I might have been able to justify a few classes---they fulfilled P.E. credits, at least---but I couldn't see myself pursuing dance. It just had too many perceptions of being gay. I simply could not allow myself to be perceived as gay (not that not pursuing dance stopped anyone from perceiving me as gay!). The church had told me gay was bad and I wanted to please the church. I don't think this was a conscious thought process, but in retrospect, it was there. There's a part of this fear of being gay that led me to give up acting when I did. I kept being around all these gay people. Guilty by association---or just plain guilty. I needed to get away from it. Would it have made a difference if the church had been supportive of gay folk 25 years ago? Would I have stuck with a performing arts career instead of careening around for my adult life, still not having much of any kind of career at 45? Well, we all look for scapegoats, and again, this might require serious couch time, which I'm not likely to pay for at this point. So perhaps we'll never know.
The point being, the right time for me to have been told it's okay to be perceived as gay was 25 years ago. It's too late, at least for the dance career (although I seem to be building a resume as a dance writer---not a bad substitute, but substitute all the same). But it could be just in time for some good Lutheran boy who is in his teens, looking at clothing design, or visual arts, or any number of things that is seen as "too gay" and thinking, "I don't want to be seen as gay." Or a nice Lutheran girl who is being told that working on cars or pursuing sports is a little dyke-y.
This affects everything. And chronos is always running out for someone. When will there be kairos?
It's Tuesday and there are doubts and the euphoria is passing and there are rumblings about sinister plans afoot. On Tuesday, it's difficult to know what to think with any real conviction.
Monday, April 6, 2009
Holy Week
Did the dissipation begin on Monday? Probably. We're fickle that way. The TV show, the pop song, the actor we admire and laud on one day is out of favor almost as soon at the peak in popularity is attained. I'm sure it wasn't quite that way in first century Jerusalem---the 21st century seems especially efficient in disposing it's heroes---but I doubt human nature has changed all that much over the centuries. We keep looking for the person who will make everything better for us---save us---and when we find that person lacking in anyway, we blame them for letting us have unrealistic expectations.
The ELCA council has passed the resolutions and statements for inclusion in the Churchwide Assembly this summer. This is a great hurdle for those of us hoping for full inclusion in the church. It is not the final hurdle. It is, in fact, painful news to some in the church. We're all looking at this moment and we're not sure where it will end and those greeting the news with palm branches may still be mourning---or worse, simply disillusioned and cynical---by Friday. Those who are fearful now my be celebrating soon.
I hope I've made it clear by now, over the course of this blog, how much it pains me that there is this great divide, this great confusion over whether or not the news is good news.
But it's only Monday in Holy Week. Who can see what Friday will bring? Much less the following Sunday . . .
Saturday, April 4, 2009
This Violent Present
In the middle of this "economic downturn," it seems people are taking up arms and randomly killing other people before killing themselves. It's a response to hardship that I don't particularly understand, but it is one that bears prayer and vigilance. Do I know anyone who, upon losing a livelihood, is likely to barge into some public place and open fire? Do I know anyone who will feel such a failure at providing for family that s/he will murder the whole family rather than ask for help? No one comes to mind, but if I did, what would I do?
I just read an essay speaking of the failure of the American dream, of people buying into the land of opportunity and feeling angry at not getting their piece of the pie. But this has always been true. Isn't this the story of the 1930s? Didn't Steinbeck write about that? What has happened to us as a culture that we turn to violence so quickly and easily? It's an old story for a failed businessman to take his own life---what is it that makes someone takes his (and let's face it, this appears to be a male phenomenon---no need to work so hard at inclusive language) own life, but not before taking out a dozen (give or take) others first?
Is it a sense of entitlement? We're Americans and we can pull ourselves up by the bootstraps and if we can't, then we're taking it out on as many people as we can? Is this the rugged individualism that has been warned about for decades, suddenly taken to it's most violent extreme?
It's easy to point to our fascination with violence in our entertainment. Violent movies and video games continue to make a lot of money and it's easy to blame the makers of these things for desensitizing us to violence, for making us violent. I think, however, that the fact that violence has become such a big part of our entertainment is only symptomatic of the violence that is exploding around us these days. Maybe it's simply a chicken/egg question: Which comes first, the violent entertainment or the hunger for violent entertainment?
A gay tangent---back in November, when California voted to repeal the right for same-sex couples to marry, there was immediate responses with rallies of protest, some of which reported some property damage and violent speech. (I don't know of any physical attacks on humans, much less killings.) This worried me. I understood the anger, but not the expression of it in property damage and threats. I don't know how this ties in, other than this blog is supposed to be about GLBT and religion and it seems that there is a certain segment of the GLBT population that is getting fed up with what it sees as religious people interfering with their lives.
I guess the connection is that we're all so . . . tightly wound, I guess. Everyone is feeling betrayed, belittled, disenfranchised . . .
The most disheartening thing is that people are getting angry and violent when they are affected. We're not getting angry when someone else is getting disenfranchised in some way. It does, in fact, seem to be an "every man for himself" scenario. Live and let live until you're the one being affected.
We've lost the humility, perhaps, to say, "It can happen to someone down to street, it can happen to me." Instead, we have only the pride to say, "This can't be happening to me and someone has to pay."
I'm at a loss, and this isn't why I started this blog, but this is where my mind is tonight.
Let us pray for our nation, our neighbors, our vigilance in watching and caring for our neighbors, and our own state of mind should misfortune befall us. We're very sick. Pray for healing.
Friday, April 3, 2009
What Draws Us Toward God
18The wrath of God is being revealed from heaven against all the godlessness and wickedness of men who suppress the truth by their wickedness, 19since what may be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them. 20For since the creation of the world God's invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse.
21For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor gave thanks to him, but their thinking became futile and their foolish hearts were darkened. 22Although they claimed to be wise, they became fools 23and exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images made to look like mortal man and birds and animals and reptiles.
24Therefore God gave them over in the sinful desires of their hearts to sexual impurity for the degrading of their bodies with one another. 25They exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served created things rather than the Creator—who is forever praised. Amen.
26Because of this, God gave them over to shameful lusts. Even their women exchanged natural relations for unnatural ones. 27In the same way the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed with lust for one another. Men committed indecent acts with other men, and received in themselves the due penalty for their perversion.
After my post last night, I've been thinking about what has drawn me toward God. The ironic answer has been the fact that I'm gay. For many gay people, this sends them away from God, or at least the church, God's representative to many people. True, my initial disgust and shame at being gay is what sent me to God in intense prayer, asking for change, cure, redemption. It is the intense prayer that, in turn, brought me to an understanding of the wideness of God's mercy, love, redemption.
I also thought of these famous verses from the first chapter of Romans. These are well known to GLBT Christians, as they are one of the handful of "clobber" passages used against us. Setting aside the fact that this is in the first chapter of Romans and that in the eighth chapter, Paul goes to some length to tell us that nothing can separate us from the love of God in Christ (making me think that maybe Paul was setting up the problem in chapter one and solving it in chapter eight), let's look at what these verses actually say.
"For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor gave thanks to him, but their thinking became futile and their foolish hearts were darkened. Although they claimed to be wise, they became fools and exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images made to look like mortal man and birds and animals and reptiles. Therefore God gave them over in the sinful desires of their hearts to sexual impurity for the degrading of their bodies with one another."
Here, Paul clearly sets up a cause and effect situation. The effect is turning people over to sinful desires, to sexual impurity. The cause was people not glorifying or giving thanks to God.
As I struggled to find peace with my own sexuality, this made no sense to me. From as early as I could say so, I wanted to go to church. I was the kid who wanted to go to Sunday school and looked forward to it. I never had a "rebellious" stage in college but was very involved in Lutheran Campus Ministry the whole time I was there. (My mother once joked that I got my degree in theater, but I majored in campus ministry.) I searched my life for a time where I was not part of a worshiping community or not seeking out a worshiping community. I'd spent my entire life, to the best of my ability, glorifying and giving thanks to God.
Why had God turned me over to "sinful desires" and "sexual impurity?"
I won't belabor the point, as I believe it's right there. I suppose there are people who would argue that I had not worshiped, glorified, or gave thanks in the proper manner, not "in spirit and truth." It's why there are some people who pray for a million dollars and get it while others don't.
But I'm not hear to debate a prosperity/"name it, claim it" theology. I'm here to simply say that if God turned me over to sinful desires, God also used it to draw me closer and to ultimately convince me that the desires weren't inherently sinful anymore than a straight man's desire for a woman is inherently sinful (although I confess that I know something about the sinful desires, too---perhaps we all do).
Being gay is a thorn in my side. It is also my blessing. It is not the same for all people. For some it's never a thorn, for others it's never a blessing. But this is my story and it's sticking to me.
Thursday, April 2, 2009
Time Well Spent and Wasted
But as I feel all these other pressures on me these days and wondering what to write about here . . . I'm coming to the conclusion that there really are more important things than talking and talking and talking again about being gay in the church. All the time, energy, and resources we put into studying and discussing . . . is this really time well-spent?
Okay, so some think that the fact that I respond emotionally and physically to people of my sex is inherently sinful. I used to think that, too. Spent a few hours wailing and praying. A few hours? It was a few years, but I can't claim I spent all that time wailing. Some of it was spent just numb. But a lot of praying.
I suppose here is the irony, and one that I wish I could, as I said a couple of posts ago, download into a flash drive: it was all those years praying and listening for God that finally gave me rest about my sexuality. Maybe "rest" is too strong a word for it, but some measure of peace. I'm not going to recount it all now, and early on somewhere, I linked a Whosoever piece I wrote over 10 years ago that outlines that experience. What I mean to say is that after years of struggle and even some years of no struggle, but numbness, God intervened and said, basically, you have bigger things to worry about.
I honestly do believe the church has bigger things to worry about, too. We do some good things on the hunger front, but there are still hungry people. We do some good things on the caregiving front, but there are still people in need of care. We do some good things on the education, evangelism, and worship fronts---and we do a lot of dissemination of lies and half-truths about any number of things, not only in regard to homosexuality.
Is all this talk and talk and talk time well spent? Maybe. If it draws us close enough to God to hear that we have more important things to deal with. (I'd like to keep open the possibility that God does think all this wrangling over sexuality is worthwhile, but I just don't believe God does. But if we draw close enough to hear God, maybe we can know for sure on that, too. )
In an illustration from a 4th or 5th century preacher (I'll try to look up the name---I have it here somewhere, but I post it in a reply another time), we are told to think of God as in the center of a circle and we're all on the edge of the circle. As we move closer to God, we cannot help but move closer to each other, as the circle gets smaller and smaller.
I don't even know what that might mean for the decisions to be made this summer at Churchwide Assembly. I just believe it to be true. I'm clinging to the hope that all this talk and talk and talk might actually draw at least some of us closer to God and we'll all end up closer to each other.
Wednesday, April 1, 2009
Mystery
Science has not yet come to a place of predicting sexuality, in part because it hasn't been able to pinpoint a cause for sexuality. Latest studies suggest that while sexuality is set very early in life, it might be determined by a few different things, or perhaps the right combination of a few certain things. We don't know of a gay or straight gene. We don't know that hormone levels in a mother at a precise moment in gestation determines sexuality. We do know that for some it appears to have a genetic component and for some it appears to have to do with a mother's hormones or maybe even birth order. The problem is that there are exceptions to every pattern (which is the most we have---patterns), and the patterns are different between gay men and lesbians.
So, since we no longer have the anticipation and wonder about the sex of a child, could we replace that with anticipation and wonder about the child's sexuality? Who will s/he have a crush on as puberty sets in? Who will s/he take to the prom? Seems like there should be some wonder and mystery about children.
Okay, I'm only half serious about this post. (The other side of that is it's only a half joke, I suppose.) It's not really intended as an April Fools post, but I'm just really swamped with other things right now (must remember next year to not take on a writing assignment that will be due the week before Holy Week!) and this was the best I could do for today. That makes two not so serious posts in a row. The lent police will be after me before long.
We'll see if tomorrow is any better.
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Weddings
Should I live so long as to find a man I want to marry and the sentiment is mutual (and I suppose that's the tricky part, eh?), I'm perfectly fine if some people don't approve. Wouldn't it be nice for those who disapprove (for whatever reason) to have a ceremony at which to officially disapprove?
Or something like that.
Sort of short on thoughts tonight. And long on other things to accomplish before I lay my head down. Perhaps I'll be pithier tomorrow . . .
Monday, March 30, 2009
In Memoriam
He was not a close friend. He was a senior (maybe he'd just graduated, I'm not sure) and I'd just completed my first year in college. I went to Southwest Texas State University (now simply Texas State University) so I only knew him because he'd picked up a few SWT Lutherans on the way to a regional retreat that previous spring.
By that time, he knew he was going to seminary, probably was on a pre-sem track at TLC, although I don't know that. He was clearly pastor material. He had a natural leadership style that drew people to him, he clearly cared about people, and had a sense of humor that made him likeable. He was not showy about any of that, but a nice, quiet Lutheran boy.
Years later, I reconnected with him, if only superficially. By this time, he was a pastor in Louisiana and I was working in Austin, TX, at Augsburg Fortress, back when AF had a regional distribution point there. I went to Synod Assemblied for AF, setting up the assembly bookstore and such. We chatted some there. He talked a bit about his parish, how much he loved it, how well they treated him. No details except for that mutual love between a pastor and his congregation. When I teased him about staying in a first call for so long, he cited this love as the reason why he's never looked for a second call.
Then one day at lunch (I lived half a block from work at the time), I called my mother and after we'd talked about whatever it was I called her for, she said, "Didn't you talk about a _________." I said, yeah, he's now a pastor in Louisiana. He had some familial connection to someone in my hometown and there was a notice in the weekly paper that he had died. It was a bit shocking to say the least.
I don't remember how I found out he had died of AIDS related causes. I do know that I called around to other LSM friends, people who knew him better than I did, and it turned out everyone was as shocked as I was. He'd told no one that he was HIV+. Through the years, I kept running into people who knew him and slowly I pieced together the story that he'd known his HIV status for some time, but that he had promised himself that he wouldn't tell anyone until he had worked up the nerve to tell his mother.
This was before the current therapies that make HIV more manageable. This was back when a HIV+ diagnosis was a ticking timebomb and anything could be the last illness. He finally got up the nerve to tell his mother he was HIV+ when he was suddenly hospitalized with something. (I don't remember what---I want to say it was some stomach or intestinal infection that went ballistic in no time.) He died shortly thereafter, within weeks as I recall. It was especially fast, given how so many people with AIDS had extended, lingering deaths at the time.
This was my first personal AIDS related death. There was much that no one knew about his circumstances. He had, in fact, had a blood transfusion at some point and he was, in fact, gay and had a secret partner in the town where he pastored. Trying to figure out where he picked up the virus, however, is more about our desire to place blame somewhere than it is about the final outcome, which is that this pastor was dead, no one had known he was sick, and he left behind someone who was treated as "only a friend."
Understand, this was back when I was still not gay-positive. This was even before I'd gone to seminary, and I've already confessed that I wrote a papter in seminary about why GLBT folk shouldn't be allowed to serve in the ministry. Even feeling as I did about that, I still understood that there was someone who was more like a family member who could not sit on the family pew at the funeral. He was invisible to everyone except for maybe one or two people, and he was, reportedly, bitter toward the church about this.
What did I feel? I can't really remember, not exactly. I was sad for his death. I felt that he was very likely a very good pastor. And I probably felt he shouldn't have had a boyfriend and if he got the virus through sexual behavior, he shouldn't have been having that sexual behavior. All that feels very cold to me now, very judgmental and lacking in compassion, but I at the time I'm sure I felt plenty compassionate. I felt badly for the partner, who felt abandoned, invisible, unable to express his grief as a widower, but at the same time, I probably felt something like, "well, but he shouldn't have put himself in that position anyway, he shouldn't have been a pastor's boyfriend."
Even now, I don't use his name (although I'm sure there are people who could read this and know who I'm talking about) because I'm not sure if his mother ever knew about his partner. I don't know if his mother ever knew that he was gay. You'd think by now, she'd find out. But, you know, he would be approaching 50 at this point, and who even knows if his mother is still alive? All I'm saying is I don't want someone to be googling him and find my blog and have that as the source for "outing" him.
That's not the most important thing right now.
He remains on my mind today because we sand "Lift High the Cross" yesterday and on Friday we had a Lutherans Concerned meeting that is organizing to see to it that there are no more secret partners left behind (although I imagine there are some secret heterosexual partners left behind here and there, too---secret lovers are not the exclusive domain of homosexuals). He remains on my mind because his presence in my mind spans my pre-coming out days, my days of actively stating he shouldn't have been a pastor despite his many gifts for it, and my current days of being something akin to an activist (although I think activists are much more active than I am and I shouldn't use the term for my feeble efforts to the cause). He becomes a symbol of a personal journey and a symbol of how things used to be and a symbol of why things must change.
But before I make him only a symbol, I have to remember he was a man who picked up some Lutheran students for a weekend retreat one spring, who went on to seminary, and became a beloved pastor. He was a person with all the strength and frailty of any human being.
And he remains on my mind tonight because we sang "Lift High the Cross" yesterday.
Saturday, March 28, 2009
Stories Beget Stories
I can't plug in a flash drive and download my experience into your experience. However many ways we're alike, that will always make us all "other." Language, culture, genetics . . . these might bind some of us, but push far enough, and you're going to find someone not "me" in the other person's skin.
I keep searching for ways to tell my coming out story so that it makes sense for those who are not gay. I can understand that. Try as I might, I don't quite understand what it means to be heterosexual. The problem in not fully understanding comes when we use that lack of understanding to prohibit one another just because we lack that understanding.
I think I mentioned the friend who took me seriously when I asked him when he first realized he was straight. Of course, he didn't have the same experience of "coming out" as straight as GLBT folk have, but as I talked about how, post-coming out, I could look back and make more sense of different events in my life, that triggered something for him. Of course he wouldn't have said "oh, I realized I was straight when . . . " but he did say, "you know, I think I must have been straight as a preschooler, too, because I remember thinking this one girl was the most beautiful thing I'd ever seen and I couldn't stop looking at her."
I am so thankful for his taking my life and my story seriously enough to think about his own. How does someone know if one is gay or straight? Maybe we don't know how we know, but once we are able to name it, several things in life begins to line up and make sense. We begin so see patterns in our life that has to do with our attractions, which goes beyond body and sexual organs. I have great rapport with women, generally, I'm attracted to their company. In the same way, straight men are attracted to other men in the sense they often seek out spaces without women---sports bar, poker games, hunting trips. These attractions aren't sexual, but neither are they complementary. Straight men and women often speak of feeling like the opposite sex completes them, even as they also desire interaction with their own sex.
Gay men speak of seeking that sort of completeness with another man. Lesbians speak of finding a connection beyond physical with another woman. It doesn't "make sense" in the same way that you can say a man and a woman being completed by each other "makes sense." But if the world made sense, there wouldn't be a duckbill platypus, either.
Another way to describe what happens. I presume (and have observed) that there is am attraction between men and women that is just something that happens, isn't planned, isn't thought out. In the vast majority of cases, this is not acted upon in any physical way, it just is, and it may not even be acknowledged most of the time. At some point, this attraction can cross a line into lust or even obsession, but for the most part, it's just attraction.
So often, homosexual desire is dismissed with "that's not love, that's lust." Well, in some cases it may be lust, but for the most part, it's just attraction. In the course of a day, I'll see any number of men I find attractive, but I don't lust after them, I don't become obsessed with them, I certainly don't have sex with them. More often than not, it's a passing thought, "oh, he's handsome." I don't ever have that sort of passing thought about women, although I assume (and have observed) that straight men do. It's just attraction. It's how were wired. It's only as interesting or disturbing as you want to make it.
I've long since drifted into rambling, so I'll give it up for tonight. I guess what I'm saying is that "understanding" may be overrated and looking for similarities is useful only to a point. We share many things, but ultimately we're all different. I believe this is part of God's plan, maybe in part so that we can better relate to God, who is Really Different from us. And I guess I'm trying to say that while we're hardwired for attraction, our attractions are different. (Gentlemen prefer blondes---except for the ones who prefer brunettes. Or balding.) It seems really far fetched to say that attraction is neutral or even a gift from God, except when we don't understand the attraction or don't have the same attraction.
That's all. For tonight.
Friday, March 27, 2009
Lutherans Concnerned
But the gathering of people was very much encouraging. Some specific tasks were outlined and people were stepping up to take them on.
Most heartening was to hear stories. Some were, of course, very sad. The story of the teenager who blew his brains out because he was homosexual, went to the church for counsel and was rejected. The ending to this story was that a pastor was turned to being more open because he realized that he did not want to be part of a church that drove kids to suicide. Another story was of a woman who felt rejected by the church and was on the verge of suicide until she saw a Reconciling Lutheran congregation run an ad on cable tv. She claims to this day that this church saved her life. There were happier stories, of how a gay or lesbian pastor influenced someone's life, or how a gay member had a positive impact on a congregation. These were stories told just in passing---we weren't about the business of telling stories tonight, but they just happen spontaneously. It appears to me that there is so much already happening in the church with GLBT folk in the middle of it, positive things, life-saving things---It appears to me that God is already moving. The church needs to catch up to God.
If you're Lutheran or in any way closely affiliated with Lutherans, one way you can help the effort is to go to the Lutherans Concerned page and click on the Reconciling Lutherans link. This is a page where you can make a public statement of welcome to GLBT, even if your congregation is not Reconciling. That's a national effort and we need names from all 50 states. Spread the word as you see fit.
(And for those who don't support the effort---I'm sure you can find the other side's efforts easily enough. I say get involved and follow your conscience. I'm sure that whatever happens this summer won't be the last of the conversation. I do hope our---note first person plural---conscience is guided by some real study and prayer and the church will catch up with God sooner than later. )
I'm mostly bouyed by the number of heterosexual folk at the meeting tonight. I am thankful, so very thankful for them. As I said before, it'd difficult to be your own advocate, but it's easier to feel energized when you feel the support of advocates.
Work to be done. Work to be done. So much work God has already done.
Thursday, March 26, 2009
Lacking
Here. Here's what I'll post. I've said earlier that spending this blogging time everyday takes me to some darker places that I like to think I've left behind. Reading the Lutheran article, especially that the committee constructing the document couldn't come to any kind of consensus, and that the tentative document that they gave us basically says, "well, if we're going to do this, this is the first step, but we're not sure we should take it" . . . along with my ongoing lack of understanding of how we can spend so much time on so few verses that barely address our current understanding of sexuality while glossing over text after text about wealth . . . along with hearing the story from my co-worker the other day (see previous post) . . . I feel a bit numb.
It's nights like this that I wonder why I bother with the church at all. Mind you, I tried leaving the church. Sort of. For a few weeks here and there. I joke that my baptism seems to have taken an especially tight hold upon me that I keep getting called back to the church. Or else I enjoy being the center of negative attention. I'm at peace with God. You'd think that would be enough. But it's God who is doing the calling, nudging me back to church when I've tried to leave. God wants me in the church, as near as I can tell, but it feels too often like all I am to the church is a problem. That's more melodramatic than I like to be, but I'll let it stand.
I'm tired, and this is too much typing for having nothing to say. Nothing new, anyway. Maybe tomorrow will be more substantive.
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
Anger Management
My church is doing a version of the Book of Faith initiative, which (for the non-ELCAers) is a national push to get everyone reading and studying the Bible. There isn't a national program per se, and each congregation is free to work out how they're going to do it (if they do it) and at my church, we have a retired engineer who along with a committee, has set up a daily reading schedule for us, with very short readings so as to not be overwhelming. It's not like those "read the Bible in one year" programs, where if your miss a day, you have enormous reading to do to catch up again. This is manageable, even if you have to catch up a couple of days at once. Then we have several different groups meeting throughout the week that members can attend to discuss what they're reading. We're about halfway through Luke right now.
The readings this week include the "lilies of the field" section, among other teachings on money and "security." I found myself getting worked up over how easily we read these sections and say, "well, Jesus didn't mean this literally," or "that's just impractical, you have to plan for your retirement" or other such comments.
And it seems just very unbalanced that we are able to do this with quite a few teachings from the Bible, most of them having to do with money or the poor, and yet we hold inviolable the handful of verses that refer to homosexuality, even if none of them address a committed, faithful relationship much less a scientific understanding of sexuality. We can make excuses for storing up goods, and even for other things like really strong teachings about divorce, but we can't quite bring ourselves (speaking for the whole institutional church) to make excuses for a sexual attraction that occurs naturally, has nothing to do with choice, and could be lived according to all the other rules of the Bible. This makes me angry.
Then yesterday, I heard a coworker, a young woman, a lesbian, talk about how she grew up in a church, and is feeling like God is calling her back to church, but she keeps hearing the condemnations of the church. She told the story without anger or bitterness, but a matter-of-factness that was even more heartbreaking than if she'd been fuming mad. Every church appears to her as if she'll be condemned if she enters the door. Or if she enters the door, she has to keep a big part of herself "private" or, rather, secret. It wasn't a situation where a long conversation was possible and the company wasn't really conducive to a serious conversation. So I wrote down my church's website and gave it to her, told her where we were located, and said to give us a try sometime. And maybe I'll follow up with her in the coming days.
But her story is just so common and so . . . well, heartbreaking is the best word I have for it. She feels like she's done nothing wrong, that she can't help but be attracted to women, but she still feels condemned by the church. And how much does my voice weigh against the weight of all the voices she's heard from the churches she's known? I don't know, but I told her how I'd been there and found some level of peace, if not with the church, then with God, and services are at 8 and 11 every Sunday morning. Come as you are.
Tuesday, March 24, 2009
Old Thoughts
Read it here.
Monday, March 23, 2009
A Lesson From Physics
I've often used this illustration with the performing arts. You can't control what the audience sees because you can't control what the audience is looking for. And sometimes, the audience does influence the performance, whether they're finding what they're looking for or not. (It works both ways with performance, of course. Sometimes the performers get the audience they're looking for.)
Similarly, I find it one of the great mysteries of my religious life that some people read the Bible and grow in judgment while others read the Bible and grow in grace.
I think I'll just leave it at that today.